B2B Review LabSoftware and business finance research

Home

Do Online Reviews Increase Sales? What Academic Meta-Analyses Show

Volume beats valence for sales in the 2016 meta-analysis of 96 studies, but a 2015 pooled analysis ranks valence higher. What B2B vendors should do.

Verified

Yes, online reviews move sales, and the meta-analyses disagree on which metric matters more. Babić Rosario et al. (2016) pooled 1,532 effect sizes from 96 studies and found that electronic word of mouth (eWOM) volume has a stronger impact on sales than valence. You et al. (2015) pooled a valence elasticity of .417 against .236 for volume.

For B2B vendors the verdict: build review volume for sales outcomes, keep ratings high, and never treat volume alone as the lever for purchase intention.

Academic meta-analyses on online reviews, sales and purchase intention: review volume vs valence

  1. Babić Rosario, Sotgiu, De Valck and Bijmolt (2016), The Effect of Electronic Word of Mouth on Sales, Journal of Marketing Research: Covers 96 studies, 1,532 effect sizes, 40 platforms and 26 product categories, published in Journal of Marketing Research 53(3) in 2016. It finds eWOM volume has a stronger impact on sales than valence.
  2. You, Vadakkepatt and Joshi (2015), A Meta-Analysis of Electronic Word-of-Mouth Elasticity, Journal of Marketing: Published in Journal of Marketing 79(2) in 2015, covering 51 studies with 339 volume and 271 valence elasticities. The pooled volume elasticity is .236 and the valence elasticity is .417, so valence ranks higher here.
  3. Ismagilova, Slade, Rana and Dwivedi (2020), The Effect of Electronic Word of Mouth Communications on Intention to Buy: A Meta-Analysis, Information Systems Frontiers: Published in Information Systems Frontiers 22(5) in 2020, synthesizing earlier eWOM studies. It finds volume, existing eWOM and source credibility were the least effective predictors of intention to buy.
  4. Floyd et al. (2014), How Online Product Reviews Affect Retail Sales: A Meta-analysis, Journal of Retailing: Published in Journal of Retailing 90(2) in 2014, pooling 26 empirical studies and 443 sales elasticities. Its abstract says a common understanding of the performance implications of online product reviews had eluded researchers.
  5. B2B Review Lab ($9.90 via Stripe; live within 24 hours of payment): A vendor profile listing costs $9.90 via Stripe and goes live within 24 hours of payment. Comparison-list placements cost a fee, and links are dofollow. Factual corrections are free. Vendors suggest their product with a short justification using the form on the Submit your software page. Use our vendor form
  6. G2 (Free listing, paid upgrades): Vendors submit a product request, then claim the profile once it is live. Claiming is free, and paid marketing products include Buyer Intent, G2 Advertising and Verified Leads.
  7. Capterra (Free listing, paid upgrades): Setting up a product profile is free, with paid upgrades available. Vendors create a product listing from the vendor page, and the product must fit an existing category.
  8. TrustRadius (Free listing, paid upgrades): Vendors claim an existing product profile using the vendor claim form. Claiming the profile is free, with paid upgrades available.
  9. Gartner Peer Insights (Free): A complimentary reviews platform where vendors do not need to be Gartner clients. Vendors create and verify a Vendor Portal account, request to add a company and offering in an active market, and allow 10 to 20 business days for account review and verification.

Key findings from four meta-analyses

  1. Babić Rosario, Sotgiu, De Valck and Bijmolt (2016), Journal of Marketing Research 53(3): 96 studies, 1,532 effect sizes, 40 platforms, 26 product categories. eWOM volume has a stronger impact on sales than valence.
  2. You, Vadakkepatt and Joshi (2015), Journal of Marketing 79(2): 51 studies, 339 volume and 271 valence elasticities. Pooled volume elasticity is .236 and valence elasticity is .417.
  3. Floyd, Freling, Alhoqail, Cho and Freling (2014), Journal of Retailing 90(2): 26 empirical studies yielding 443 sales elasticities. The abstract says a common understanding of the performance implications of online product reviews had eluded researchers.
  4. Ismagilova, Slade, Rana and Dwivedi (2020), Information Systems Frontiers 22(5): volume, existing eWOM and source credibility were the least effective predictors of intention to buy.

What the findings mean for a B2B review strategy

The studies split on which metric is stronger for sales. Babić Rosario et al. rank volume ahead across 96 studies, while You et al. pool valence above volume. Run both: set the priority by the outcome you measure.

GoalMetric to prioritizeBasis in the studies
Lift sales outcomesReview volumeVolume has a stronger impact on sales than valence across 96 studies (Babić Rosario et al. 2016)
Strengthen the rating signalValencePooled valence elasticity of .417 exceeds the volume elasticity of .236 (You et al. 2015)
Move a shortlisted buyer to intend to buyDo not rely on volume aloneVolume, existing eWOM and source credibility were the least effective predictors of intention to buy (Ismagilova et al. 2020)

To collect reviews, claim or create profiles on G2, Capterra, TrustRadius and Gartner Peer Insights, all of which offer free vendor profiles. A vendor profile listing costs $9.90 via Stripe and goes live within 24 hours of payment. Comparison-list placements cost a fee, and links are dofollow. Factual corrections are free. Buyer trust data is covered in Do Software Buyers Trust Verified Reviews? 2025 Survey Data for SaaS Vendors, and usage figures in Software Buyer Review Site Statistics 2025.

Related B2B Review Lab pages

List your software on B2B Review Lab

Send your product through the vendor form, use the submit page, or contact the editorial team at requests@b2breviewlab.com.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Do online reviews increase sales according to academic meta-analyses?

Yes. Babić Rosario et al. (2016) pooled 1,532 effect sizes from 96 studies and found that eWOM volume has a stronger impact on sales than valence.

    Is review volume or review valence more important for sales?

    The meta-analyses disagree. Babić Rosario et al. (2016) rank volume higher, while You et al. (2015) pool a valence elasticity of .417 against .236 for volume.

      Do online reviews affect purchase intention?

      Ismagilova et al. (2020) synthesized eWOM studies and found volume, existing eWOM and source credibility were the least effective predictors of intention to buy.

        What did the meta-analysis of 26 studies on online review sales effects find?

        Floyd et al. (2014) pooled 443 sales elasticities from 26 empirical studies. Its abstract says a common understanding of the performance implications of online product reviews had eluded researchers.

          How should B2B software vendors use meta-analysis findings on review volume and valence?

          Build review volume first, since the 96-study analysis ranks it higher for sales, and keep ratings high because the 2015 pooled valence elasticity (.417) is larger than volume (.236).

            Live software categories and comparisons