Categories › Manufacturing Execution Systems (MES) Software
Compare OpenMES and Tulip for teams building or adapting shop-floor apps, with deployment, low-code tools and machine connectivity in view.
Verified
6 of 7 publish a price
Why it ranks here: OpenMES lists OPC UA, MQTT and Modbus for IoT and SCADA machine connectivity.
Not a fit if: you need a free hosted Community edition; OpenMES Community is self-hosted.
Why it ranks here: Tulip’s no-code editor builds customizable production apps and dashboards for shop-floor devices.
Not a fit if: you need customer-managed on-premises deployment.
Why it ranks here: ERPNext is an ERP/MRP product with a shop-floor module rather than a dedicated MES; logged low-code searches named it, and Job Cards record work by workstation.
Not a fit if: you need a paid per-license MES subscription; ERPNext is free and Frappe Cloud hosting starts per site.
Why it ranks here: qcadoo MES lists Wonderware SCADA integration for shop-floor data.
Not a fit if: you need customer-managed hosting; the commercial edition is SaaS.
Why it ranks here: A modular low-code architecture configures plant workflows.
Not a fit if: you need batch or process production apps; PINpoint is built specifically for discrete manufacturing.
Why it ranks here: Batch Procedure is a low-code tool for production control, batch processing, procedures and workflows.
Not a fit if: you need low-code tools for discrete production apps; Sepasoft Batch Procedure covers production control, batch processing and workflows.
Why it ranks here: Odoo Manufacturing is an ERP/MRP product with a shop-floor module rather than a dedicated MES; logged low-code searches named it, and Odoo Studio customizes apps without code.
Not a fit if: you need a dedicated MES product; Odoo Manufacturing is an ERP/MRP module with shop-floor work orders.
Start with OpenMES for low-code shop-floor apps: OpenMES lists OPC UA, MQTT and Modbus for IoT and SCADA machine connectivity.
The logged low-code searches named Odoo Manufacturing and ERPNext Manufacturing; these ERP/MRP products use shop-floor modules rather than dedicated MES products, which is why they are included in this comparison.
Choose OpenMES when self-hosting and OPC UA, MQTT or Modbus connectivity fit the plant; choose Tulip when operators need a no-code editor for production apps and dashboards.
| Product | Choose it for | Documented capability for this need | Commercial boundary |
|---|---|---|---|
| OpenMES | Machine connectivity protocols: OpenMES lists OPC UA, MQTT and Modbus for IoT and SCADA machine connectivity. | OpenMES lists OPC UA, MQTT and Modbus for IoT and SCADA machine connectivity. Vendor source | Community is free. Enterprise costs €500 net per installation monthly or €5,000 annually. |
| Tulip | Low-code shop-floor app building: Tulip’s no-code editor builds customizable production apps and dashboards for shop-floor devices. | Tulip’s no-code editor builds customizable production apps and dashboards for shop-floor devices. Vendor source | Essentials starts at $100 per interface per month and Professional at $250 per interface per month, billed annually; each has a 10-interface minimum. Enterprise and Regulated Industries require contacting sales. |
| ERPNext Manufacturing | Shop-floor module fit: ERPNext is an ERP/MRP product with a shop-floor module rather than a dedicated MES; logged low-code searches named it, and Job Cards record work by workstation. | ERPNext is an ERP/MRP product with a shop-floor module rather than a dedicated MES; logged low-code searches named it, and Job Cards record work by workstation. Vendor source | ERPNext is free and open source; Frappe Cloud hosting starts at $5 per site per month. |
| qcadoo MES | Machine connectivity protocols: qcadoo MES lists Wonderware SCADA integration for shop-floor data. | qcadoo MES lists Wonderware SCADA integration for shop-floor data. Vendor source | Published BASIC and OPTIMAL prices are per license per month, with a five-license minimum. |
| PINpoint MES | Low-code shop-floor app building: A modular low-code architecture configures plant workflows. | A modular low-code architecture configures plant workflows. Vendor source | Pricing is custom for each facility, process and workforce. |
| Sepasoft MES | Low-code shop-floor app building: Batch Procedure is a low-code tool for production control, batch processing, procedures and workflows. | Batch Procedure is a low-code tool for production control, batch processing, procedures and workflows. Vendor source | Perpetual per-site and per-server module licenses; public module prices start at $9,100. |
| Odoo Manufacturing | Low-code shop-floor app building: Odoo Manufacturing is an ERP/MRP product with a shop-floor module rather than a dedicated MES; logged low-code searches named it, and Odoo Studio customizes apps without code. | Odoo Manufacturing is an ERP/MRP product with a shop-floor module rather than a dedicated MES; logged low-code searches named it, and Odoo Studio customizes apps without code. Vendor source | Odoo publishes subscription plans for access to its applications; Odoo Online is hosted and Enterprise can be on-premise or Odoo.sh. |
See all MES comparisons.
Buyer guides: Openmes pricing · Tulip pricing · Erpnext Manufacturing pricing · Qcadoo Mes pricing · Sepasoft Mes pricing.
Buyer guides: Tulip alternatives.
Pricing guide: Odoo Manufacturing pricing.
The order follows logged AI search mentions, answer position, then documented fit to this page’s criteria; there is no numeric score.
| Product | Low-code shop-floor app building | Deployment model | Machine connectivity protocols | Production model supported | Published pricing model |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OpenMES | Not documented[1] [2] | Community is self-hosted; Enterprise is available on-premises or in the cloud.[3] [2] | OPC UA, MQTT and Modbus are listed for IoT and SCADA machine connectivity.[2] | Vendor documentation names discrete, process and mixed-mode production.[4] | Community is free. Enterprise costs €500 net per installation monthly or €5,000 annually.[3] [5] |
| Tulip | Tulip’s no-code editor builds customizable production apps and dashboards for shop-floor devices.[6] [7] | Tulip describes its composable MES as cloud-native; its on-premises connector host is an integration component, not a separate MES deployment.[8] | Tulip connects machines through Node-RED, MQTT, and OPC UA directly or through edge devices; OPC UA and MQTT connectors are documented.[9] [10] | Tulip documents discrete manufacturing apps and electronic batch record workflows for batch manufacturing.[8] [11] [12] | Essentials starts at $100 per interface per month and Professional at $250 per interface per month, billed annually; each has a 10-interface minimum. Enterprise and Regulated Industries require contacting sales.[13] [13] |
| ERPNext Manufacturing | Not documented[14] [15] | ERPNext can be self-hosted or hosted on Frappe Cloud.[16] | Not documented[14] [15] [17] | ERPNext names discrete and process manufacturing use cases.[14] | ERPNext is free and open source; Frappe Cloud hosting starts at $5 per site per month.[16] |
| qcadoo MES | Not documented[18] [19] | The commercial qcadoo MES edition is offered as SaaS.[20] | Wonderware SCADA integration is listed; data direction and protocols are not stated.[21] | Not documented[18] [19] [22] | Published BASIC and OPTIMAL prices are per license per month, with a five-license minimum.[23] |
| PINpoint MES | A modular low-code architecture configures plant workflows.[24] | Not documented[25] [26] [27] | Device-specific drivers connect TCP/IP and OPC devices; OPC Write sends a value to a PLC when a process step begins.[28] [28] | PINpoint is built specifically for discrete manufacturing.[26] [24] | Pricing is custom for each facility, process and workforce.[25] |
| Sepasoft MES | Batch Procedure is a low-code tool for production control, batch processing, procedures and workflows.[29] | The architecture guide documents servers on-premises or in the cloud.[30] | OPC UA collects production counts, equipment states and quality data; MQTT is recommended for multi-site architectures to reduce bandwidth.[30] | Sepasoft documentation covers discrete, process and batch manufacturing.[31] | Perpetual per-site and per-server module licenses; public module prices start at $9,100.[32] |
| Odoo Manufacturing | Odoo Studio customizes apps without coding and documents building an app from scratch.[33] | Odoo offers Odoo Online hosting and on-premises deployment.[34] | Odoo documents OPC UA support through its IoT box.[35] | Odoo documents continuous production workflows and batch output registration in Shop Floor.[36] [36] | Standard: €24.90 per user per month billed yearly or €31.10 billed monthly. Custom: €44.90 billed yearly or €56.90 billed monthly. Light User: €7.90. One App Free: €0 for one app and unlimited users. Odoo localises prices by visitor region; these are the EUR prices shown to a request from Finland.[37] |
A simple guide to the free, open-source factory management system. Built for small and mid-sized manufacturers. Track production, check how well your machines work, plan orders, manage quality, and connect your equipment – all in one place.
OpenMES Enterprise gives manufacturers everything the free Community edition offers — and then adds the modules, services, and guarantees that large-scale, multi-site, and regulated operations need. On-premise or Cloud
OpenMES is a powerful, free, and open-source Manufacturing Execution System designed to streamline production processes, enhance visibility, and drive operational excellence in modern manufacturing environments. Self-hosted · Docker
Whether the factory runs discrete manufacturing, process production, or mixed-mode operations, you are the expert who makes it work.
Monthly plan: €500 net per month. Annual plan: €5,000 net per year. One Subscription covers one Installation. Each additional Installation requires a separate Subscription.
Create guided workflows, management terminals, and dashboards, built on your common data model and with no coding required.
Create fully customizable apps and dashboards you can easily run on mobile devices, tablets, desktops, and wearables - without writing a single line of code.
Cloud-native from day one, Tulip’s architecture is designed to scale and is highly extensible – enabling companies to create technology stacks with connections with other systems and the physical world.
Communicate bi-directionally with your machines to automate machine set points. Connect via Node-RED, MQTT, and OPC UA directly or through Tulip’s edge devices.
Capture machine attributes by connecting Tulip to your OPC UA server or your MQTT broker with pre-built connectors to Highbyte, Litmus, HiveMQ, etc.
The platform captures a complete genealogy record for every item produced. It links the serial number to the operator, the machine, the specific tool readings, and the materials consumed, providing a complete digital history of the build.
Tulip's platform aligns with FDA 21 CFR Part 11 and EudraLex Annex 11 requirements for electronic records and signatures.
Ideal for basic production visibility, quality, and assembly workflows.
ERPNext's powerful manufacturing capabilities make it suitable for any discrete or process manufacturing use case. ERPNext also supports complex engineer to order workflows.
A Work Order is a document given to the manufacturing shop floor by the Production Planner as a signal to manufacture a certain quantity of a certain Item. The Actual Operation Time, Actual Operating Cost, Actual Start Time, and Actual End Time are updated when Job Cards are updated.
Frappe Cloud is Frappe's own managed hosting platform for simple, reliable, and secure hosting of Frappe applications like ERPNext. Sites $5 onwards /mo Start small and run a single site with multiple apps on shared servers.
IoT integration (not in-built) allows real-time shop floor updates, eliminating paperwork and streamlining operations.
Qcadoo to program do zarządzania produkcją i magazynem dla małych i średnich firm produkcyjnych.
In qcadoo MES you may record the raw materials used, finished products manufactured, working time of the employees and the equipment, people in charge of specific operations, and product batches. Your production hall workers can focus on their duties instead of spending time on entering data into a computer. This is why we provide you with a very simple and intuitive dedicated terminal where one can swiftly and efficiently record the performed operations.
qcadoo MES is available as commercial SaaS, but we have also Community Edition. It is fully Open Source, based on AGPL licence.
qcadoo MES is integrated with most popular warehouse and sales systems. This will enable synchronization of information between the systems on-line so that you don’t have to enter the same data twice, and thus will put all your data in order. Currently we have integration with Polish software, but we are open to other integrations. Currently qcadoo MES is integrated with most popular ERP systems on Polish market: Integracja qcadoo MES z Subiekt GT Integracja qcadoo MES z Comarch ERP Optima Integracja qcadoo MES z enova qcadoo MES can be integrated with other software used in your company. We have integration with label printing software Bartender, integration with SCADA system from Wonderware or integration with ZEBRA printers.
The Genealogy feature of qcadoo MES comes in handy here.
Licencja qcadoo MES kosztuje od 145 do 205 zł miesięcznie, zależnie od pakietu (BASIC lub OPTIMAL) i sposobu płatności. Każdy pakiet można przetestować bezpłatnie przez 30 dni.
PINpoint MES is built specifically for discrete manufacturing environments. Built on a modular, low-code architecture, PINpoint MES can be configured to your plant’s specific workflows and terminology. Our experienced implementation team helps you get results fast—often starting with just one line, station, or process area.
All you need is some server space and a computer at every workstation. As long as it’s Windows, use the hardware you want.
Error-proof manufacturing and improve production efficiency with PINpoint Manufacturing Execution System. The only comprehensive no-code, out-of-the-box MES for discrete manufacturers.
All you need is some server space and a computer at every workstation. As long as it’s Windows, use the hardware you want.
The Data Manager is a Windows service that manages communication between the physical world and client applications. The Data Manager has three main modules: •Device Manager: provides a communication layer between TCP/IP, and OPC devices using Device specific drivers (e.g., Open Protocol Tools, PLCs, Stack Lights, Tester Devices, PINpoint BigScreens, etc.).
The Sepasoft Batch Procedure system is a low-code tool for developing flexible production control in batch processing as well as procedures and automated workflows.
If each site uses OPC UA to communicate with plant floor equipment to collect production counts, equipment states, quality information, etc., and each site also supports hundreds of user sessions, this architecture will consume considerable network bandwidth. Using MQTT instead of OPC UA is recommended in this type of architecture and will help reduce bandwidth usage.
A Process Cell represents a production line of any type of manufacturing: Continuous Process Converting Line Discrete Manufacturing Packaging Line
OEE Downtime Module Perpetual Site License. Unlimited OEE calculations per physical production site license. $22,700 SPC Module $9,100
Odoo Studio is a toolbox to customize Odoo without coding.
Odoo Online or Odoo Enterprise (On-premise or Odoo.sh) is the same software. Only the hosting and infrastructure are different: emails, backups, database redundancies, etc.
The Open Platform Communications (OPC) Unified Architecture (UA) protocol is now supported by the IoT box.
Continuous production lets manufacturers process work orders in partial quantities.
One App Free; €0; One app, unlimited users. Standard; 24.90 € (Yearly); 31.10 € (Monthly); / user / month. Custom; 44.90 € (Yearly); 56.90 € (Monthly); / user / month. Light User at 7.90 €.
Send a correction with a source link and we review it against the vendor's own documentation.
Suggest a correction
